Is Download's first female headliner a milestone or a 'bittersweet' moment?

Linkin Park will make history this weekend as the first female-fronted band to headline the UK's biggest rock festival.

Download, held at Donington Park, Leicestershire, has traditionally been dominated by male-led groups such as Iron Maiden, Slipknot, and Metallica since it began in 2003.

This year, Linkin Park and lead singer Emily Armstrong will close out the three-day rock and metal festival on Sunday night.

The presence of a woman at the top of the bill this year has been hailed by some fans as a milestone, but others say it's not quite the step forward for diversity it appears to be.

Linkin Park reformed in 2024, seven years after original frontman Chester Bennington took his own life.

Chester Bennington's family also criticised the band with his son, Jaime, accusing remaining members of "quietly erasing" his father's "life and legacy".

The choice of Emily Armstrong upset some fans, who pointed to her alleged ties to the Church of Scientology and past support for US actor and convicted rapist Danny Masterson.

Armstrong has distanced herself from Masterson, stressing that she does not condone any "abuse or violence against women".

Despite the friction, their comeback single The Emptiness Machine reached number four in the UK top 40, and reaction to them topping the Download bill has been generally positive.

On his way into the festival, Linkin Park fan James Harvey tells BBC Newsbeat Armstrong is "a really good fit", and says it's a sign the scene is "changing for the better".

The 22-year-old says getting more diverse headliners might "take a while" but the future is "going to get even better".

'It's the bare minimum'

Lambrini Girls bassist Selin Macieira-Boşgelmez tells BBC Newsbeat that women in the rock scene are "often plagued with imposter syndrome".

"Partially because we are so under-represented in alternative music," she says.

Selin formed the English punk rock duo with Phoebe Lunny in 2019 and, in 2025, the pair landed the grassroots Loud Women Hercury Prize and were nominated for Rolling Stone UK's Rising Stars Award.

But, she says, it was difficult for them to get a foothold in the industry.

"In terms of even seeing myself in it, I very often would just go through my male friends that were musicians," says Selin.

"I think that part of the problem is that they're often not really given the chance on account of not being taken seriously."

Selin feels that "loudness and aggression" - key elements of heavier genres - are often "celebrated in men and demonised in women."

Selin says seeing Armstrong top the Download bill is "bittersweet".

"It is kind of the bare minimum," she says.

"I think that's a problem across the whole industry, not just this particular festival."

BBC Newsbeat has asked Download Festival's organisers for comment.

British radio host Sophie K says festivalgoers should be celebrating positive changes and not attacking Emily for being the first.

"I'm over the conversation about criticising festivals for their headliners," she says.

Sophie K co-hosts the On Wednesdays We Wear Black podcast with Yasmine Summan which gives a platform to under-represented voices in rock and metal.

As one of the first black women to host an alternative radio show in the UK, Sophie says fans "should be thanking Linkin Park for choosing a queer woman to front their band".

"They could have chosen anyone."

Co-host Yasmine Summan says seeing Armstrong headline a major festival is "really validating" but "there definitely is always room for more."

Summan says growing up and seeing her co-host Sophie as a "loud and proud black woman in rock music" has been "incredibly important".

Summan says one reason for slow progress on representation is down to risk-taking.

"Doing creative jobs often isn't considered for queer people, for brown people, for women, because it's really hard for us to exist."

They hope that Emily Armstrong shows people that it's "a viable career option".

Yasmine also feels that music listeners and fans have to play their part too.

"You guys need to start telling festivals what bands you want to listen to, if enough people want this artist at a festival they get booked for it."

Listen to Newsbeat live at 12:45 and 17:45 weekdays - or listen back here.