Counterfactual generation aims to simulate realistic hypothetical outcomes under causal interventions. Diffusion models have emerged as a powerful tool for this task, combining DDIM inversion with conditional generation and classifier-free guidance (CFG). In this work, we identify a key limitation of CFG for counterfactual generation: it prescribes a global guidance scale for all attributes, leading to significant spurious changes in inferred counterfactuals. To mitigate this, we propose Factored Classifier-Free Guidance (FCFG), a flexible and model-agnostic guidance technique that enables attribute-wise control following a causal graph. FCFG complements recent advances in classifier-free guidance and can be seamlessly extended to advanced guidance schemes such as CFG++ and APG. Our experiments demonstrate that FCFG significantly improves the axiomatic soundness of inferred counterfactuals across both natural and medical image datasets, mitigating spurious amplification effects, and enhancing counterfactual reversibility.