Large Language Models (LLMs) have improved substantially alignment, yet their behavior remains highly sensitive to prompt phrasing. This brittleness has motivated automated prompt engineering, but most existing methods (i) require a task-specific training set, (ii) rely on expensive iterative optimization to produce a single dataset-level prompt, and (iii) must be rerun from scratch for each new task. We introduce TATRA, a dataset-free prompting method that constructs instance-specific few-shot prompts by synthesizing on-the-fly examples to accompany a user-provided instruction. TATRA requires no labeled training data and avoids task-specific optimization loops, while retaining the benefits of demonstration-based prompting. Across standard text classification benchmarks, TATRA matches or improves over strong prompt-optimization baselines that depend on training data and extensive search. On mathematical reasoning benchmarks, TATRA achieves state-of-the-art performance on GSM8K and DeepMath, outperforming methods that explicitly optimize prompts on those tasks. Our results suggest that per-instance construction of effective in-context examples is more important than running long, expensive optimization loops to produce a single prompt per task. We will make all code publicly available upon acceptance of the paper. Code is available at https://github.com/BMD223/TATRA