Simultaneous speech-to-text translation systems must balance translation quality with latency. Although quality evaluation is well established, latency measurement remains a challenge. Existing metrics produce inconsistent results, especially in short-form settings with artificial presegmentation. We present the first comprehensive meta-evaluation of latency metrics across language pairs and systems. We uncover a structural bias in current metrics related to segmentation. We introduce YAAL (Yet Another Average Lagging) for a more accurate short-form evaluation and LongYAAL for unsegmented audio. We propose SoftSegmenter, a resegmentation tool based on soft word-level alignment. We show that YAAL and LongYAAL, together with SoftSegmenter, outperform popular latency metrics, enabling more reliable assessments of short- and long-form simultaneous speech translation systems. We implement all artifacts within the OmniSTEval toolkit: https://github.com/pe-trik/OmniSTEval.