Catherine McCafferty is an actor, stand-up comedian, and apparently a fun date. As host of webseries Pretty Gay, McCafferty has taken an enviable roster of LGBTQ suitors on mock first dates, getting to know them through a variety of fun games, flirty banter, and raunchy conversation.

Pretty Gay gained attention in 2024 after featuring Dropout's Vic Michaelis, followed by other well-known figures, including Smosh's Angela Giarratana. It's since continued to grow, with McCafferty building a playful camaraderie and supportive community with her predominantly sapphic guests. Dating her way through prominent online personalities and entertainers, McCafferty has accumulated 419,000 followers on Instagram, 155,300 on TikTok, and 45,400 subscribers on the Pretty Gay YouTube channel, with clips from the show gaining millions of views.