A man who spared his ex-girlfriend jail after she had their sex tapes sent to his new lover has accused her of throwing his mercy back in his face.
Kristina Taylor, 36, was charged with sexual cyber harassment on October 27 and faced two months in jail until the man she wronged intervened.
The property investor, who asked to not be identified, told the Daily Mail he insisted to the state's attorney they not receive any jail time, or he would refuse to cooperate.
'I'm not trying to ruin anybody's life, I knew I wouldn't feel comfortable sending [her] to jail,' the 45-year-old previously told the Daily Mail.
But now Taylor and her ex are back in court over a house they bought six months before their four-year relationship collapsed last September.
A lawsuit he filed in Polk County, Florida, accuses Taylor of swindling him out of the $525,000 four-bedroom house in Lakeland, Florida.
The scorned lover claimed she also refused to reimburse him more than $18,000 to pay off Taylor's debts, including $12,000 for surgeries, so she would qualify for the mortgage.
The type of surgery was not specified, but in photos shared by Taylor she appeared to have had multiple cosmetic enhancements.
Kristina Taylor, 36, was arrested for sending a screen recording of her chats with her ex-boyfriend to her friend, who forwarded it to the man's new lover
Taylor's ex-boyfriend, 45, (pictured) moved on just weeks after she dumped him
The couple rented together for two years before looking for a home to buy where they could live as a family with Taylor's two children.
They 'intended to get married and purchased the property with the intention of living there as their marital home', the lawsuit explained.
However, the boyfriend's investment business was too new to meet the lender's requirements and they were forced to put the house in her name only.
The lawsuit claimed this was done with the intention of later adding his name to the title, which was agreed to in writing.
'Despite not qualifying for the loan, [the man] was gainfully employed and paid most if not all the funds to purchase the property,' the lawsuit claimed.
This included $18,375 for the down payment, a $10,000 real estate commission, $2,000 in landscaping, $2,000 for repairs, and $2,701 for home insurance.
He claimed to also pay $4,014 a month in mortgage, plus $800 to $900 a month in utilities, $120 a month for pool maintenance and $1,400 for lawn care.
Taylor's only contribution to the house was $1,500 a month towards the bills, the lawsuit claimed.
This went on until Taylor abruptly dumped him a few days after a Labor Day trip to Dallas with a friend.
Taylor and her ex are back in court over a house they bought six months before their four-year relationship collapsed last September
Then on September 19, she filed for a domestic violence injunction in which she claimed she was afraid of him and he was harassing her and had forced her from their home.
Her ex had just 20 minutes to pack up and leave the house when police suddenly arrived to serve the order, and had to petition the court to retrieve the rest of his belongings.
The restraining order was later dismissed, and expired in February.
The lawsuit claimed Taylor then changed the locks and attempted to sell the house without his knowledge.
Property records showed the house was put up for sale at $559,000 the same day, then listed for $4,400 a month rent when it failed to sell.
The house struggled to find a tenant and was instead put on Airbnb for $439 a night, according to its listing as a 'Luxury Home with Heated Pool, Family/Pet Friendly'.
'Beautifully decorated two-story home in a desirable South Lakeland community of custom homes,' the listing read.
'This spacious retreat features 4 bedrooms, 2.5 baths, and a private luxury heated pool in a fully fenced yard - perfect for kids and pets.
'Close to shopping, dining, lakes, and parks, while enjoying a quiet, upscale neighborhood. Comfort, style, and location all in one.'
A lawsuit filed in Polk County, Florida , accuses Taylor of swindling him out of the $525,000 four-bedroom house Lakeland, Florida
The lawsuit claimed profits from the Airbnb income were not shared with Taylor's ex-boyfriend, which constituted unjust enrichment.
His complaint seeks to have a lien put on the property to prevent it being sold, and demands Taylor reimburse him for all his contributions to the home or sign it over to him.
Comment was sought from Taylor but she did not respond. Her lawyers filed a standard response to the lawsuit denying the claims against her.
Taylor was charged along with her meddling close friend Tara Johnson, 36, and could have faced up to a year in prison.
The victim began dating another woman, whom the Daily Mail has agreed not to identify, and Johnson found out after a mutual friend saw a photo of them together on Facebook.
Johnson contacted the woman through Facebook and told her she 'had concerns about [his] character,' according to charging documents.
Taylor's friend then told the new girlfriend of the allegations made in the restraining order application, and claimed he was still with Taylor when they started seeing each other, the Daily Mail understands.
'When [the new girlfriend] asked for proof of the allegations against [her boyfriend], Johnson then asked Taylor for proof,' charging documents explained.
'Taylor then provided screenshots and pictures for Johnson to provide to [her].'
Taylor was charged with sexual cyber harassment for sending the recording with the intimate images to her friend without her ex's consent
Johnson sent the new woman (pictured) the recorded conversations, which included thumbnail-sized previews of the man's penis and graphic videos of them having sex
Among those was a screen recording of some of the chat history between Taylor and her ex-boyfriend, including intimate photos they sent to each other.
The X-rated images included thumbnail-sized previews of his penis and graphic videos of them having sex.
The victim's new girlfriend told him that Johnson was talking about him to her, but didn't mention the screen recording until mid-October.
He called police on October 16 and the Polk County Sheriff's Office took statements from both women.
Johnson admitted to sending the video, but claimed she didn't know it contained the sex tape because she stopped watching after she saw a photo of Taylor's bare breasts.
The Daily Mail understands the pair were instead offered a misdemeanor diversion program that included hours of community service and supervision, completion of which would allow them to avoid convictions.
Court documents indicated the diversions were underway since their last court dates.
The Polk County State Attorney's Office refused to provide more information about the terms of the diversions while they were yet to be completed.
Taylor's friend Tara Johnson, 36, tracked the new woman down and forwarded the chat history that Taylor sent her, which included previews of the ex-boyfriend's penis and videos of them having sex
Taylor and Johnson celebrated avoiding jail time with lengthy Instagram posts that alluded to their legal woes without mentioning them directly - and both painting themselves as the real victims.
'About seven months ago, everything I knew about my life got completely stripped away from me - the life that I thought I was living, the house that I lived in, the relationship I was in... you name it. It has been insanity,' Taylor said in a video.
Johnson resigned from her job as executive director of Hope House Florida within days of being charged.
Her abrupt departure and resulting negative publicity plunged the charity, which provides resources and a home for new and expectant mothers to stay during their pregnancies and the first few months after giving birth, into turmoil.
By early this year the organization had still not replaced her, and announced the house would close. It was later put up for sale at $1.25 million.
Hope House would instead become an affiliate of Hope House Colorado and pivot towards being a resource center for teen mothers aged 15 to 21, as Colorado is.