When I first enquired about running a Golf R, I expected this to be a swansong of sorts. The eighth-generation VW Golf was to be the last, we were told, as the electric ID.3 filled the family hatchback-sized hole in the Volkswagen range.

Thankfully, reports of the Golf’s demise were a little premature. Volkswagen had a change of heart, deciding it was better not to abandon the model names people know and love. The ‘ID.’ prefix would now denote versions with battery power, as with the new Polo and electric ID. Polo. So yes, a ninth-generation Golf and ID. Golf are coming down the tracks. 

Does this mean the flagship VW Golf R will live on? Almost certainly. However, there’s a strong possibility, like the forthcoming Polo GTI, that it could be reinvented as an EV. So this petrol ‘R’ might still mark the end of an era. 

All of which brings us back to the question I posed previously: should you buy a VW Golf R while you still can?

VW Golf: More fuel, less luggage

My first long-term test report dusted off the history of Volkswagen’s flagship ‘R’ badge, then the second update focused on how the Mk8 Golf R drives. 

For this third and final instalment, I’ll discuss how the car was to live with as a daily-driver. From school runs to racking up motorway miles, KU75 ZYW did it all.

Let’s deal with the practical stuff. If you’re used to driving A.N. Other mid-sized crossover, you might find the Golf on the small side for a family car. This is exacerbated by the 4Motion four-wheel-drive system, which eats into boot space, shrinking it by 40 litres to 341 litres.

Fuel economy could be better, too. I managed 31.7 mpg overall, versus an official average of 34.5mpg, but the numbers dropped into the mid-20s when stop-starting around town. Fill the 55-litre tank with super unleaded, as per Volkswagen’s recommendation, and this 333hp hatch won’t be cheap to run. 

That said, group 34E insurance (out of 50 groups in total) is lower than I had expected. And the ‘R’ still resides at the more affordable end of the performance car spectrum. 

Inside the VW Golf R

Inside, the Golf offers a very configurable driving position and nicely supportive bucket seats. I prefer their grippy ‘microfleece’ fabric to leather trim, too.

Many words have been written about the Mk8 Golf’s woeful infotainment, so I won’t reopen old wounds here. Suffice to say it was much improved after the mid-life ‘Mk8.5’ update, introduced in January 2024 – and as tested here. 

Indeed, I found the latest system quick to respond and intuitive to navigate. I also connected my phone quickly and reliably using Apple CarPlay. My only ongoing gripe is with the haptic controls on the steering wheel spokes, which are fiddly and easy to activate by mistake.

In contrast to reports of earlier cars, it’s also worth saying the software in ‘my’ Golf was glitch-free. All I’d ask is for an easier, one-touch way to turn off the lane assist and speed limit bongs that are, regrettably, mandated in every modern car.   

Masterful at making progress 

Not that I was speeding everywhere, you understand, but when you do want to ‘make progress’, few cars do so as effectively as a Golf R. Despite the showboating Drift mode introduced for this Mk8 version, this car’s forte is covering ground in a fast and fuss-free manner.

At times, the VW Golf feels a bit too competent for its own good, something brought into sharp focus when I borrowed an immaculate Peugeot 205 1.9 GTI restored by Auto Rara (pictured above). Despite having little more than a third of the Golf’s output, the classic 205 felt energetic and exuberant where the ‘R’ seemed coolly efficient.

Then again, few people would choose to daily-drive a 205 GTI in 2026, and the ‘R’ worked its way into my affections over time. Whatever else I’d been road-testing that day, from a restomod Porsche 911 to the latest Chinese SUV, it always felt reassuring to climb back into my long-termer. Because, let’s face it, most of our journeys aren’t on the kind of roads where a hot hatchback can really shine. And when it isn’t going fast, the ‘R’ does an excellent job of just being a Golf. More than 37 million owners can’t be wrong, right?

A magnet for have-a-go heroes

Even in dark-and-moody Black Edition spec, as seen here, the Golf R looks quite subtle – especially when parked alongside a Honda Civic Type R or Mercedes-AMG A45 S. Nonetheless, perhaps because of its trademark ‘R’ Lapiz Blue paint or big-bore Akrapovic exhaust (which looks meatier than it sounds), the Golf did attract a certain kind of attention. Put simply, it feels like every other hot hatch owner wants to race you.

At times, such as when I chased an Alpine A290 GTS along a brilliant B-road, this rivalry is quite enjoyable. At others, like when I was cruising calmly on the M25, it could be annoying. Interestingly, I’ve rarely experienced the same reaction to a Golf GTI, whether it be my own Mk5 or the Mk8.5 GTI I tested in 2024. 

The comparison with the GTI is a critical one, as the Golf R’s sibling also feels, in some respects, like its closest competitor. Is the ‘R’ worth the £5,000 premium? Unless you really want or need four-wheel drive, I’d argue not. Yes, the GTI is slower, but it’s also lighter and more engaging to drive. 

As a serial Golf GTI owner, I’m also a sucker for red go-faster stripes, tartan seats and the iconic status of the GTI badge. From my (very subjective) standpoint, it seems to outshine the Golf R. 

End of a long-term loan

And so my time with the Volkswagen Golf R comes to a close. It’s fair to say this eighth-generation car didn’t scale the same heights as its brilliant Mk7 predecessor – and the high prices still asked for Mk7s suggest the market feels the same. 

Nonetheless, the latest Golf is a well-rounded hot hatchback that fitted effortlessly into my life, and added a dash of excitement to even very mundane journeys. It’s expensive, at £46,930 (or a hefty £58,820 as tested here), but in a world where you can spend £50,000 on a Toyota GR Yaris, all things are relative. 

I would happily have carried on living with the ‘R’ – and my car-agnostic partner felt the same. It’s a car that covers a lot of bases very well. Even if, in the final analysis, I’d rather have a new Golf GTI.

• Tim Pitt writes for Motoring Research