Unexpected Business Lesson in Product Design: Make Commitment Achievable

At the center of the podcast is a simple but deliberate structure of roughly 20 minutes per day. That duration reflects an understanding of how people adopt new behaviors: short enough to be manageable, but long enough to feel meaningful.

“If it’s too short it would not feel like it was worth the commitment,” Schmitz explained. “We needed to have an amount of time that felt significant enough, but not overly complicated and not impossible. It’s accessible every day.” Director of consumer products and media at Ascension, Marisa Beyer, described the execution behind that simplicity, noting, “We had to make the breaks happen at points in the narrative that made sense, so there wasn’t too much covered in a single episode.” Together, those decisions created a format that users could realistically sustain over time.

Unexpected Business Lesson: Know Your Audience and Be Willing to Adjust Early

One of the most instructive decisions came before launch, when the team reconsidered the podcast's positioning. The original concept, The Catholic Bible in a Year, was changed after the team recognized it might unintentionally limit its reach.

The script and marketing assets had been prepared, and Schmitz had recorded several episodes when “there was this moment of thinking, ‘we are missing something,’” Beyer recalled. “This approach could be limiting, and it doesn’t need to be that way.” Schmitz reinforced that shift from a content perspective: “This is for everybody. Yes, it is Catholic and unabashedly so, but this is for everybody.” The adjustment broadened the invitation without changing the substance.

A similar adjustment emerged in how the content was structured. Early versions of the plan would not have introduced the Gospels – the books of Jesus’ disciples Matthew, Mark, Luke and John that are the foundation of Christian faith – until late in the year. That approach was reconsidered once the team looked at the experience through the listener’s lens. As Schmitz put it, “People might get a little impatient if they don’t hear from Jesus until Halloween.” The solution was to introduce “Messianic checkpoints,” bringing the Gospels forward in intervals throughout the year. The change reflects a practical form of customer empathy: understanding not just what content to deliver, but when and how audiences need reinforcement to stay engaged.

Innovation is often equated with constant reinvention. The Bible in a Year Podcast offers a useful counterpoint: in many cases, the advantage comes from committing to a well-designed model and executing it consistently.

The unexpected business lesson for business is that understanding your audience is not just about targeting the right segment. It is often about removing unnecessary friction that prevents people from engaging in the first place. Another lesson is that thoughtful innovation before launch and strong execution can drive scale.

Unexpected Business Lesson: Servant Leadership as an Operating Model

While the podcast appears to center on Schmitz’s narration, its execution depends on a coordinated team. Schmitz noted that at least 19 people contributed to each episode, underscoring the team effort behind the output.

“It is not false humility to recognize that this would be impossible if it was just me,” he said, adding, “This is God’s work; I just got to be the narrator.” Beyer emphasized that the program's success challenged the Ascension team to reconsider what they might achieve that they previously would not have thought they were capable of, due to their collective effort.

The leadership model is about clarity of roles and shared ownership over visibility. For executives, that translates into a practical reality: scalable systems depend on alignment across teams, not on individual performance alone.

Unexpected Business Lesson: Durability Comes From Trust, Not Spikes

The podcast’s growth trajectory runs counter to the dominant media model. It did not rely on viral moments or continuous reinvention but instead built momentum through repeat engagement and word of mouth.

"When you have something that works, it does what it’s supposed to do,” Schmitz said. Jeff Cavins is a co-host of several podcast episodes and created The Bible Timeline that the podcast follows. Cavins pointed to the broader context at launch on January 1, 2021, saying, “it drew people at a time during COVID, at a time when everything was so uncertain, people were searching. People were desperate to know God’s story.”

Ascension CEO Jonathan Strate framed the distinction in business terms, saying, “Quick growth often depends on spikes of attention, but durability depends on trust. We promised the entire Bible, one step at a time. That promise turns listening into a daily practice rather than a single moment of consumption.” That trust is reinforced through consistency, with additional content added over the five years since the podcast was launched, “to build the trust that sustains it long after the initial excitement fades,” Strate added.

Unexpected Business Lesson On Platform Strategy: Balance Reach with Ownership

The podcast is distributed widely across major platforms, but Ascension also invested in its own app to deepen engagement. That decision reflects a deliberate balance between reach and control.

As Josh Rudegeair, Ascension’s director of app and communications, explained, “The Ascension app allows us to support that ongoing journey in a way other podcast platforms simply can’t.” The app extends the experience beyond listening, offering additional context and engagement that standard platforms do not provide. “That deeper engagement matters because it’s what sustains momentum,” he added.

For business leaders, this highlights a familiar tradeoff: third-party platforms enable scale, but owned channels offer deeper customer engagement that builds relationships.

Unexpected Business Lesson: Extending the Model Without Diluting It

Ascension is now applying the same structured approach to new offerings, including an instructional Mass video by Schmitz, a Mass in a Month podcast launching May 1 with Dr. Edward Sri and a co-authored guide to the Mass.

Each follows the same core principle: breaking complex or lengthy material into manageable, time-bound experiences. This consistency reinforces the broader strategy of growth through disciplined execution rather than constant reinvention.

Unexpected Business Lessons For Leaders

The success of The Bible in a Year is notable, and its broader relevance lies in the model behind it. The unexpected business lessons are clear: design for sustainable engagement, understand your customer, remove barriers early, align teams around clear roles, build trust through consistency, and balance reach with ownership. Those choices are not always clear in a time of constant noise and rapid iteration, but they are what tend to endure.

Did you enjoy this story on unexpected business lessons? Don’t miss my next one: use the blue “follow” button at the top of the article near my byline to follow my work, and check out my other columns here.re.